The New Orleans Saints’ selection of quarterback Tyler Shough with the 40th overall pick in the 2025 NFL Draft has sparked considerable discussion among fans and analysts. Shough, a 25-year-old quarterback from Louisville, brings a unique combination of experience and resilience to the team.
Shough’s collegiate journey is notable for its length and diversity. He began his career at Oregon, transferred to Texas Tech, and concluded at Louisville. Over seven seasons, he demonstrated adaptability and perseverance, culminating in a final season where he completed 62.7% of his passes for 3,195 yards, 23 touchdowns, and six interceptions. His age and injury history have been points of contention, but the Saints see value in his maturity and readiness to contribute immediately.
The decision to draft Shough was made under the leadership of new head coach Kellen Moore. Moore, known for his offensive acumen, believes in Shough’s potential to fit into the Saints’ system, which emphasizes a balanced attack with play-action elements. Shough’s ability to make quick decisions and his strong arm are assets that Moore aims to leverage.
The quarterback situation in New Orleans is further complicated by the uncertain status of veteran Derek Carr, who is dealing with a shoulder injury. This opens the door for competition between Shough and Spencer Rattler, another young quarterback on the roster. The Saints’ investment in Shough indicates confidence in his ability to vie for the starting role.
While some analysts, like former Saints quarterback Chase Daniel, have expressed reservations about Shough’s fit in Moore’s offense, the team remains optimistic. Daniel graded the fit as a B, acknowledging potential challenges but also recognizing Shough’s capabilities .
In summary, the Saints’ selection of Tyler Shough reflects a strategic move to secure a quarterback who combines experience, resilience, and the potential to thrive under Kellen Moore’s guidance. As the team navigates the upcoming season, Shough’s development and integration into the offense will be pivotal factors to watch.